Colorado Supreme Court

The Colorado Supreme Court is the highest in the state’s judicial system and is responsible for interpreting and applying the law, resolving disputes, and ensuring justice for all.

Established in 1876, the same year as Colorado’s statehood, the Colorado Supreme Court has a rich history and legacy of upholding the rule of law, protecting individual rights, and promoting public welfare.

As the Colorado Supreme Court marks its 147th anniversary, it continues to face significant challenges and opportunities in fulfilling its vital role in the legal and social landscape of the Centennial State.

From grappling with complex legal issues to addressing public concerns about judicial integrity and accessibility, the Colorado Supreme Court plays a crucial role in shaping the present and future of Colorado law and society.

This article will provide an overview of the Colorado Supreme Court, including its history, structure, jurisdiction, notable cases, and current issues. Whether you are a legal professional, a student of law, or a curious citizen, this article will offer valuable insights into one of the most essential institutions in Colorado’s governance and justice.

History of the Colorado Supreme Court

The Colorado Supreme Court has its roots in the territorial courts that existed before Colorado became a state. In 1861, Congress established the Territory of Colorado, and the first territorial governor, William Gilpin, appointed the first three judges to the territorial Supreme Court. The court had jurisdiction over all cases arising under territorial law, including criminal and civil matters and appeals from the lower courts.

When Colorado achieved statehood in 1876, the territorial Supreme Court was reconstituted as the Colorado Supreme Court. The first chief justice was George W. Allen, who had served on the territorial Supreme Court. Initially, the court had three justices, but it has since expanded to its current size of seven justices.

Over the years, the Colorado Supreme Court has played a pivotal role in shaping the legal landscape of Colorado. Some of the most notable cases that the court has decided include:

People v. Ammons (1917): This case established the rule that evidence obtained through an illegal search and seizure is inadmissible in court.
Taylor v. Colorado (2003): This case clarified the limits of free speech in courtrooms, holding that a judge may prohibit disruptive or intimidating behavior by spectators during a trial.
Coats v. Dish Network (2015): This case addressed the issue of whether an employee can be fired for using medical marijuana outside of work. The court held that employers have the right to enforce drug-free workplace policies, even if the drug use is legal under state law.

Structure of the Colorado Supreme Court

The Colorado Supreme Court is comprised of seven justices appointed by the governor and confirmed by the state senate. Justices serve ten-year terms and may be reappointed. The justices themselves choose the chief justice, who serves a five-year term.

The court’s headquarters are in the Ralph L. Carr Colorado Judicial Center in Denver, Colorado, which also houses the Colorado Court of Appeals and other judicial agencies. The building, which opened in 2013, is named after former Colorado Governor Ralph L. Carr, who opposed the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II.

The Colorado Supreme Court has a hierarchical structure, with the Supreme Court at the top, followed by the Colorado Court of Appeals and the district courts. The court also has administrative responsibilities, including overseeing the state’s judicial system, establishing rules of court procedure, and administering the bar exam.

Jurisdiction of the Colorado Supreme Court

The Colorado Supreme Court has both original and appellate jurisdiction. As an appellate court, the Supreme Court has the power to review decisions made by lower courts, including the Colorado Court of Appeals and district courts. The court hears appeals in various legal issues, including criminal, civil, administrative, and family law.

In addition, the Colorado Supreme Court has original jurisdiction in some instances, meaning it is the first court to hear the case. The court has original jurisdiction in cases involving disputes between states, challenges to the constitutionality of state laws, and cases involving the gubernatorial election or impeachment of state officials.

Notable Cases of the Colorado Supreme Court

Over the years, the Colorado Supreme Court has issued landmark decisions on various legal issues. Here are some of the most notable cases:

Lobato v. State of Colorado (2013): In this case, parents and school districts sued the state, alleging that Colorado’s school funding system violated the state constitution’s requirement to provide a “thorough and uniform” education for all students. The Supreme Court held that the current system was unconstitutional and ordered the state to revamp it.

Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission (2018): In this case, a baker refused to create a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, citing his religious beliefs. The couple filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Commission, which found that the baker had violated the state’s anti-discrimination law. The Supreme Court held that the Commission’s actions violated the baker’s free exercise of religion and ordered the case to be reconsidered.

People v. Ramos (2020): In this case, the court held that Colorado’s system of allowing non-unanimous jury verdicts in criminal trials was unconstitutional. The court overturned the convictions of two defendants found guilty by split juries.

Current Issues Facing the Colorado Supreme Court

Like many state courts, the Colorado Supreme Court faces various issues and challenges as it strives to serve the people of Colorado. Here are some of the most pressing issues facing the court today:

Judicial Ethics: The Colorado Supreme Court has been grappling with questions about judicial ethics and impartiality. In 2020, the court issued new rules governing judges’ political activities and speech. Still, some critics have raised concerns about the potential impact on free speech and the right to participate in the political process.

Access to Justice: The court has also been working to increase access to justice for all Coloradans, particularly those who are low-income or marginalized. The court has implemented a range of programs, including the Access to Justice Commission and the Colorado Legal Services Corporation, to help people navigate the legal system and access legal representation.

Technology and Innovation: As technology continues transforming the legal profession, the Colorado Supreme Court has been exploring ways to improve court efficiency and enhance access to justice. In 2020, the court launched a new online system for filing court documents, and it has also been working to expand virtual court proceedings in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

In the Colorado Court of Appeals, Rule 8 states that a party must typically make the initial motion in the district court for specific relief during an appeal, including a stay of the judgment or order, approval of a supersedeas bond, and injunction-related orders.
Rule 3 in the Colorado Court of Appeals allows an appeal of an order denying a petition filed by a minor or someone acting on their behalf by promptly filing a “notice of appeal.”
The Colorado Court of Appeals, per the law, provides transparent, impartial, and timely resolutions of appealed orders and judgments. It is responsible for assigning judges to divisions and rotating their assignments to fulfill its mission.
The Colorado Court of Appeals reviews final judgments from district courts and decisions made by state administrative agencies. It serves as the first appellate court for decisions from various Colorado courts.

FAQs

Conclusion

The Colorado Supreme Court plays a vital role in the governance and justice of the Centennial State. As the highest court in Colorado’s judicial system, the Colorado Supreme Court is responsible for interpreting and applying the law, resolving disputes, and upholding the principles of justice, fairness, and equality.

Through its rich history, groundbreaking decisions, and ongoing efforts to improve the legal system, the Colorado Supreme Court has earned its place as one of Colorado’s most respected and influential institutions. Whether you are a legal professional, a student of law, or a concerned citizen, the Colorado Supreme Court offers valuable insights and opportunities to engage with the legal and social issues of our time.