Colorado Appellate Attorney

FREE Consultation By Phone

Colorado Appeals Eligibility

Who Is Eligible To Appeal A Criminal Conviction In Colorado


Facing a criminal conviction in Colorado can leave you uncertain about your future. One key fact to know is that if mistakes were made during your trial or your rights were violated, you might have the option to appeal.

This article will explain who is eligible to file an appeal, how it works, and what outcomes you might expect. Keep reading to find out more!

Key Takeaways

  • In Colorado, anyone who believes procedural errors or violations of rights happened during their trial can file for an appeal. If the court made mistakes handling your case or didn’t respect your legal rights, you might challenge the conviction.
  • You have a strict deadline to start this process. Specifically, you need to file a Notice of Appeal and Designation of Record after the judgment is entered or post-trial motions are denied; you need to timeframe, which could mean losing your chance to appeal.
  • The appeals procedure includes several steps, such as collecting all trial documents, submitting briefs arguing your case to appellate courts, and possibly presenting oral arguments. Every document and step in this process is crucial for highlighting issues from the original trial.
  • Depending on how well your appeal demonstrates errors or rights violations that occurred during your initial trial, outcomes vary significantly—from getting a new trial to potentially having your conviction overturned. Success highly depends on showing concrete evidence that these mishaps impacted the fair outcome of your case.
  • Suppose one level of court doesn’t favorably decide an appeal. In that case, the case can be escalated higher through Colorado’s system to the Colorado Supreme Court by requesting further review through petitions for certiorari.

Understanding the Basis for Filing an Appeal in Colorado


In Colorado, individuals challenge their criminal convictions by filing an appeal on specific grounds. This process begins when someone believes a procedural error or rights violation affected the trial’s outcome.

Procedural Errors

Procedural errors in criminal cases often lead to the filing of an appeal. These errors can include incorrect jury instructions, mistakes made by the judge, or prosecutor misconduct.

These issues can significantly impact a trial’s outcome, making them valid grounds for an appeal. The appellate courts review cases closely for these procedural missteps.

After a judgment is entered or post-trial motions are denied, an appellant must promptly file a Notice of Appeal and Designation of Record within 35 days. This step initiates the appeals process and is critical in challenging procedural errors.

Following this, strict deadlines govern the submission of briefs to the appellate court, starting with an Opening Brief from the appellant and then moving through various stages, including responses from district attorneys and further replies if necessary.

Every document filed is crucial in highlighting procedural discrepancies during the initial trial.

Violation of rights

Moving from procedural errors, another critical basis for appealing a criminal conviction in Colorado revolves around rights violations. The Constitution guarantees individuals specific protections within the criminal justice system.

These include the right to a fair trial, protection against illegal searches and seizures, and freedom from cruel or unusual punishment. If any of these rights are infringed during the legal process, it could form valid grounds for an appeal.

Defense lawyers tirelessly work to identify such breaches by meticulously reviewing case files, police reports, and court transcripts.

Legal representation is pivotal in addressing these violations through the appeals courts. They prepare comprehensive briefs that argue how their client’s constitutional rights were compromised, relying on established case law and standards of review mandated by higher courts, including district courts, and ultimately aiming toward the Supreme Court if needed.

Successful appeals can lead to various outcomes:

  • It may lead to remanding the case back to lower courts with instructions for correction.
  • Overruling previous convictions.
  • It could lead to retrials.
  • It may lead to outright dismissal based on the severity of the rights violation encountered by defendants during their initial trials.

The Process of Appealing a Criminal Conviction in Colorado


Appealing a criminal conviction in Colorado involves steps and strict deadlines. It requires the careful preparation of legal documents and understanding the appellate process. Here’s a Here’sed breakdown:

  1. Wait for Judgment Entry: You must wait until the judgment is officially entered after the trial. This step is crucial because you can only file an appeal after it.
  2. File a Notice of Appeal: Within 35 days of the judgment being entered or any post-trial motions being denied, file a Notice of Appeal and Designation of Record in the county court that heard your original case.
  3. Prepare the Record on Appeal: Collect all documents, evidence, and transcripts from your trial to submit to the appellate court. This record will serve as the basis for reviewing your case.
  4. Submit Briefs to the Court: Your Colorado appellate attorney will prepare an opening brief summarizing case facts, legal arguments, supporting statutes, and desired outcomes. The prosecution will then submit an answer brief to contest your appeal, to which your attorney can reply with a reply brief.
  5. Oral Arguments May Occur: Both parties might present oral arguments before the appeals judges if requested by the court or deemed necessary by either party.
  6. Judges Review and Decide: The Colorado Court of Appeals or Supreme Court judges will review all submitted materials and oral arguments if presented. They scrutinize everything from legal errors to procedural discrepancies that could have affected your trial’s outcome.
  7. Await Decision: After reviewing your case, judges will issue a decision ranging from upholding your conviction to ordering a new trial or reversing it entirely based on identified errors or violations during the initial proceedings.
  8. Further Appeals Might Be Possible: If your appeal is unsuccessful at one level, you may have options to escalate it further through the judicial system, potentially reaching the Colorado Supreme Court through petitions for certiorari.

Each step requires meticulous attention to detail and knowledge of complex legal principles—traits exemplified by seasoned criminal defense attorneys specializing in appellate litigation.

Potential Outcomes of a Criminal Conviction Appeal

successful criminal conviction appeal in Colorado can lead to several significant changes. One possibility is reversing the conviction, which means the courts find a critical mistake invalidating the original judgment.

Evidence showing procedural errors or rights violations during the initial trial could reverse the conviction. Another outcome could be resentencing, where a defendant may receive a lighter sentence based on appeals court findings.

Additionally, an appellant might secure a new trial if the appellate review identifies substantial mistakes made during jury selection or in the admission of evidence without sufficient probative value.

In cases where grounds for appeal include prosecutorial misconduct or ineffective counsel assistance, this fresh opportunity for trial allows wrongs to be righted under closer scrutiny and more rigorous legal standards.

It’s worth noting that each stage (from filing objections to presenting legal briefs) plays a crucial role in determining these outcomes and reshaping someone’s life after being wrongly convicted.


Understanding your rights after a criminal conviction in Colorado is crucial. Those rights include steps from identifying procedural mishaps to challenging the jury’s verdicts on solid legal grounds.
Those who feel justice was not served have paths available to question the outcome. It takes prompt action and adherence to specific procedures, but overturning an unjust decision is within reach for those determined to seek it.
Knowledge of your eligibility and understanding of the appeal process can be powerful tools in navigating these challenging waters.


  1. What does it mean to appeal a criminal conviction in Colorado?
    Appealing a criminal conviction in Colorado means asking a higher court to review the decision of your trial to ensure no mistakes affected the verdict.
  2. Who can file an appeal after a criminal trial?
    Anyone found guilty at their jury trial or who entered a guilty plea under certain conditions might have the right to appeal, especially if they believe there was an error in legal proceedings or judgment.
  3. Are there exceptions to who can appeal?
    Individuals who accept plea bargains give up their right to appeal, except under specific circumstances, such as questioning the court’s jurisdiction or arguing their plea was not made knowingly and voluntarily.
  4. How do I start an appeals process?
    To begin the appeals process, you must file a notice of appeal with the courts of appeal within a set deadline after your conviction or sentencing. Acting quickly and consulting with your attorney or public defender is crucial.
  5. What happens during an appellate review?
    During appellate review, judges examine records from your original trial, including testimony and evidence, but have yet to hear new witnesses. They look for legal errors that could have influenced the outcome.
  6. Can appealing my case guarantee it will be overturned?
    No, appealing doesn’t guarantee that your conviction will be overturned. The appeals courts may uphold the original decision if they find no significant errors affecting its fairness or accuracy.


Scroll to Top