Colorado Appellate Attorney

FREE Consultation By Phone

Decision In Appeal

Possible Outcomes Of A Colorado Criminal Appeal

Possible Outcomes Of A Colorado Criminal Appeal

Criminal Appeals in Colorado: Understanding the Possible Outcomes

Criminal Appeals in Colorado_ Understanding the Possible OutcomesWe understand the criminal justice system in Colorado can be daunting, especially when facing a criminal appeal.

Navigating appellate courts requires deep understanding and specialized expertise. We will guide you through what to expect during this process.

The appellate review might lead to several outcomes: your conviction could be overturned, your sentence modified, or the original verdict upheld.

Achieving a reversal on appeal is challenging, underscoring the importance of an outstanding criminal defense lawyer who dedicates themselves to your case from beginning to end. As lawyers with extensive knowledge and experience in Colorado criminal law, focusing only on this specific area and constantly updating ourselves on criminal law and courtroom practice, we can make a significant difference in the outcome of your criminal appeal in Colorado.

We thoroughly examine all potential legal errors before proceeding with your criminal appeal. We prepare every possibility, fighting for a new trial if necessary and ensuring that every argument is effectively presented. Through each stage of litigation, from filing a notice of appeal to engaging in oral arguments before an appeals court panel, we stand committed to defending your rights vigorously.

The 3 Possible Outcomes of a Criminal Appeal in Colorado

The 3 Possible Outcomes of a Criminal Appeal in ColoradoIn Colorado, appealing a criminal case opens doors to three paths your appeal might take.

Each potentially challenges the trial court’s decision in hopes of a successful appeal.

Each path uniquely affects your future, offering hope for a change in conviction and sentencing.

Appellate Court Reversal of Conviction

Appellate Court Reversal of ConvictionUnderstanding the importance of overturning a conviction in Colorado’s justice system cannot be overstated, especially regarding the complex process of appealing a criminal conviction.

Overturning a criminal conviction requires a detailed understanding of the appeals process, including identifying specific grounds for appeal, such as errors in the trial or legal proceedings, and the meticulous steps necessary to file an appeal.

This process also involves a limited review by the appellate court, focusing on whether the trial court made a significant error that affected the outcome. Preparing and submitting an appellate brief that meets stringent requirements is a critical part of this process. The goal is clear: to fight relentlessly for another chance at justice by presenting substantial evidence and arguments that make judges reconsider.

Securing a reversal can lead to a new trial, where the case can be presented again. The process involves meticulously examining every part of the original trial, from how the jury was instructed to how evidence was admitted to ensuring no constitutional rights were infringed upon.

There’s rigorous preparation of reply briefs, deep engagement with standards of review, and challenging any identified ineffective counsel assistance issues. This rigorous strategy aims to address all potential grounds for appeal.

Modification of Sentence

We understand that an illegal sentencing can happen if the law is not applied correctly. This illegal sentencing means a judge might give a sentence that does not match the crime because of a mistake in understanding the law.

Our role at McClintock Law Firm, LLC, involves arguing these errors before appellate courts to seek a change in the sentenced punishment. The Colorado Court of Appeals and the Colorado Supreme Court are vital in ensuring everyone gets fair treatment under the law.

Our team works hard to present solid arguments and evidence showing why a sentence should be changed. This process may involve discussing how initial legal errors occurred or proving that crucial laws were misinterpreted during sentencing.

We leverage our specialized knowledge of criminal defense, appealing directly to higher courts like the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals where needed. We aim to protect our client’s constitutional rights by striving for just outcomes in each case we handle.

Affirmation of Conviction and Sentence

Our team understands that the appeals courts may keep a criminal case’s outcome and punishment as is. This record means that after thoroughly examining everything involved in the appeal, including legal arguments and ensuring all legal rights were respected, the appeals court sees no reason to change or adjust the original verdict. This decision confirms what was initially decided without any changes.

We prepare our clients for this potential outcome by examining every part of their case to ensure that nothing unfair or biased influenced their trial. We aim to fight against unjust convictions and unlawful sentences that go against our clients’ rights to a fair process in Colorado.

Why Choose McClintock Law Firm, LLC for Your Criminal Appeal in Colorado

Why Choose McClintock Law Firm LLC for Your Criminal Appeal in Colorado

At McClintock Law Firm, LLC, we bring specialized skills to every criminal appeals case in Colorado.

Our focus on appellate law means you get expert legal help at the county court level and up to the Supreme Court.

Our Colorado criminal defense team is dedicated to achieving the best possible outcomes for each client’s needs, leveraging extensive knowledge and experience in Colorado criminal law and procedure. 

Specialized Expertise in Colorado Criminal Appeals

Specialized Expertise in Colorado Criminal AppealsOur team specializes in appellate law, bringing an unmatched depth of knowledge to Colorado criminal appeals. 

With decades of experience behind us, our understanding of the complex legal landscape allows them to approach each case with precision and care.

Our expertise covers everything from county court cases to supreme court challenges. We excel at every step in the process, including drafting compelling writs of certiorari and arguing persuasively before a panel. This focused knowledge means we are perfectly equipped to navigate the unique complexities of appeals, such as reviewing trial transcripts for errors and crafting solid arguments that can potentially change outcomes.

We recognize every individual’s right to appeal and work tirelessly to ease this phase for our clients. We dig deep into dense legal precedents, closely examine jury instructions, and scrutinize plea agreements for any signs of unfairness or bias.

Such a thorough approach ensures we are well-prepared for retrials or adjustments in sentencing when victories are achieved on appeal. Through relentless preparation and strategic use of knowledge, we support our clients at every stage, ensuring their voices are heard at higher levels of judicial review. 

Moreover, Our attorney dedicates herself fully to each case, knowing the profound impact a successful appeal can have on a client’s life. She focuses solely on this area of criminal law to give each client the best chance of prevailing on appeal. She possess extensive knowledge and experience in Colorado criminal law, focusing solely on this area and continuously updating their expertise on criminal law and courtroom practices.

Proven Track Record of Success

With 30 years of experience in Colorado criminal law, our team has a distinguished history of navigating successful appeals. Our expertise in reversing convictions, obtaining sentence modifications, and securing new trials showcases our track record of assisting clients successfully through the appeals process.

Our achievements include securing new trials, obtaining sentence modifications, and even reversing convictions. These wins highlight a profound understanding of legal strategies and how court decisions are made. We commit to ensuring every client gets professional and personal representation, focusing on building solid attorney-client relationships. This approach helps us grasp each case’s subtle details, enabling us to present strong arguments in court.

Our skill in handling objections, assessing evidence for relevance and impact, and navigating jury trial procedures has consistently improved the outcomes for our clients’ cases at both state Supreme Court levels and courts of appeal. Our skill in assessing trial errors for relevance and impact has also consistently improved our client’s chances for a favorable outcome at all levels of the appeal process.

Professional and Personalized Representation

Professional and Personalized Representation

Look no further if you seek professional and personalized assistance for your Colorado criminal appeal. 

Our team is dedicated to hearing your side of the story, clearly explaining your options, and customizing a strategy specifically suited to your needs.

We recognize how daunting the appeals process can seem, so we’re committed to guiding you through every step with clear communication and steadfast support. Every client receives our undivided attention.

Whether it involves arguing legal errors from your trial or contesting the fairness of your sentencing, our objective remains consistent: to present the most robust case possible on your behalf at all levels—from Superior Court trials de novo to stays of execution and more.


1. What happens after filing a criminal appeal in Colorado?

After a criminal appeal is filed in Colorado, the appellate court reviews the record and considers arguments from both sides to decide whether an error affected the trial’s outcome.

2. Can new evidence be introduced during an appeal?

No, appeals focus on reviewing the trial’s procedural fairness and legal correctness based on the existing record; new witnesses or evidence are generally not admitted.

3. What are some possible outcomes of a criminal appeal?

Possible outcomes include upholding the original verdict, reversing a conviction that may lead to an acquittal, remanding for a new trial due to errors like ineffective assistance of counsel, or modifying sentencing if it’s found unjust.

4. Can my penalty increase after an appeal?

The “double jeopardy” principle prevents penalties from increasing after a defendant appeals an initial conviction in criminal cases.

5. How does one request an appeal in Colorado?

To initiate an appeal, you must file a notice with appropriate documentation, such as a designation of record, and possibly post bail through an appeal bond if you are seeking release during the process.

6. Why might someone need legal representation to appeal their case?

Legal representation is crucial because navigating complex appellate procedures requires expertise in analyzing judicial errors, drafting persuasive briefs about prejudicial issues or unfair trials, and arguing effectively before higher courts, including potentially The United States Supreme Court. Expert legal guidance is essential in appealing a trial court’s court’s decision, as it involves a thorough review and potential outcomes such as affirming, upholding, reversing, or modifying the court’s court’s verdict.

Scroll to Top